Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Steven S. Neff's avatar

This is outstanding, as always.

Here is my theory why superhero pics don’t do it:

I’m not a fan, generally, of the superhero genre of storytelling. Why? Partly Because it is so unrealistic and so alien to our regular lives. It is difficult to apply any “lessons” from those stories to our human experience.

If I have super powers, then it doesn’t really take courage to do anything. I’m above and beyond ordinary human experience. I’m “god-like” in my powers.

But humans are so deeply flawed and limited that we really can’t truly connect with a superhero on a deep level.

It is why I love stories about actual humans exhibiting courage.

For example, the movie 12 Strong is the true story of the Army Special Forces Units who rode into battle against tanks against the Taliban while on horseback after 9/11. I have a friend who served in the unit that replaced the unit depicted in the movie, and he did the same. Said he hadn’t even ridden a horse since he was about 10 years old. Then all of a sudden he’s on horseback facing Russian-made tanks of the enemy!

If we stop and think about it, do we realize how extraordinary that is? FAR more impressive to me than what a fictional Superman with superhuman strength and the ability to fly can do.

I think we need to move away from fantasy storytelling and get back to real life storytelling. That’s the stuff that “sticks” better. “If HE can do it, why not me?”

You do such a great job of that, and I thank you.

6 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?